To access the main Loglan page

## Lesson 6: Making Connections

### Lo Mipli Steti

1. La Deiv, farfu. I la Deiv, kicmu.
Dave is a father. [And] Dave is a doctor.
2. La Deiv, farfu, e, kicmu.
Dave is-a-father and is-a-doctor.
3. La Deiv, farfu la Palys, e la Djan, la Megn.
Dave is-the-father-of- Paula and -of-John [through] Megan..
Dave is the father of Paula and John through Megan.
4. La Deiv, farfu la Palys, gu, e la Djan, la Megn.
Dave is-the-father-of-Paula [through someone]. and of John [through] Megan.
Dave is the father of Paula, and of John through Megan.
5. Ba tcaro. I be torkrilu.
Something is a car. And something [else] is a bicycle.
There are cars and bicycles.
6. La Djenis, pa godzi la Paris, e la Lyndn, e la Romas.
Jenny went to Paris [and] London and Rome.
7. La Deiv, farfu ha kicmu?
Dave is a father how-connected-to being a doctor?
Is Dave a father? Or a doctor?

### Lona Cninu Purda

#### Little Words

 e and ha how-connected-to (interrogative connective)

### Lopo Lengu Klimao

You probably think this is going to be a short chapter. If so, you're wrong. It's not complicated, though; just a lot of information to wade through. Nor do you have to memorize it all. You should read through it and be sure you understand it, but don't be surprised if you have to come back to it a few times.

The subject is what grammarians call conjunctions and logicians call connectives: `and', `or', `and/or', `but', and so forth. There are fourteen of these connectives, and there are four versions of each one. However, as usual, you'll find considerable order to the system. Ultimately, there are only ten elements involved; once you know them, you will be able to reconstruct any form you have forgotten.

All you have to remember is:

• that the basic connectives are a (`and/or'), e (`and'), o (`if and only if/means'), and u (`whether')
• that no- is used before a basic connective (noa), and -noi afterward (anoi)
• that nu reverses the order of elements (ta, u ti `that [is true] whether this [is or not]'; ti, nuu ta whether this [is true or not], that [is true]')
• that nu is only used before u.

(Nuu is pronounced NOO-oo. Nu is used only to make the nuu concept easier to remember. Connectives are not predicates, so you can't actually convert them.)

We'll begin by looking at the notes for the sentences above, then we'll look at all fourteen connectives and what they mean.

Notes:

1. Basic connectives such as e (called "eks") work much the same way as `and' and `or' do in English: Just place them between the two predicates or arguments you want to join.

2. You must pause in speech and put a comma in writing before eks.

3. As mentioned, eks work with arguments as well as predicates.

4. These sentences may answer the question Ba he vi le tcastosia? `What is [there] in the parking lot?' Instead of saying Ba tcaro, e torkrilu (`Something is a car and a bicycle'), we need a second variable to act as the first argument of torkrilu. Using ba alone would mean that there are one or more things which are both cars and bikes, as the English translation above makes clear. We don't want to say that there's anything that's both a car and a bike, so we need the be.

5. You can't get away with English-style "x, y, and z" groups in Loglan; you must say xei, e ysi, e zei. Pay attention to the way these words group: ((xei, e ysi), e zei), just like modification ((mutce sadji) ridle). Eks assume that the expression to the left (the left connectand) is through, so they go on to the next one. We'll find out how to get around this in the next lesson.

7. There are fourteen answers to La Deiv, farfu ha kicmu?

La Deiv, farfu, a kicmu
Dave is a father and/or a doctor.

The point is that he may be one or the other or both. The sentence is false only if he is neither one. This contradicts the claim made by noenoi (`neither...nor...'), below.

La Deiv, farfu, noa kicmu which is equivalent to:
La Deiv, no farfu, a kicmu
Dave (not is-a-father) or [he is] a doctor.
Dave is a father only if he's a doctor.

This is false only if he's a father but not a doctor, that is, if the first connectand is true, but the second is false. (Think about it: If he is a father, then no farfu is false, and if he isn't a doctor, no farfu, a kicmu fails, because both connectands are false, and a requires at least one of its connectands to be true.) This contradicts the claim made with enoi and is the converse of the claim made with anoi, below.

La Deiv, farfu, anoi kicmu which means the same as:
La Deiv, farfu, a no kicmu Dave is-a-father and/or [he is] not a doctor.
Dave is a father if he is a doctor.

This is false only if he's a doctor but not a father, that is, if the first connectand is false, but the second is true. (If he is a doctor, then no kicmu is false, and if he isn't a father, farfu, a no kicmu fails, because both connectands are false, and a requires at least one of its connectands to be true.) This contradicts the claim of noe.

La Deiv, farfu, noanoi kicmu which is equivalent to:
La Deiv, no farfu, a no kicmu.
Dave (not is-a-father) or (not is-a-doctor).
Dave is not both a father and a doctor.

He can be one or the other -- or neither, for that matter -- but he can't be both. It contradicts the claim of e.

La Deiv, farfu, e kicmu
Dave is a father and a doctor.

He must be both, or the sentence is false. It contradicts the claim of noanoi, above.

La Deiv, farfu, noe kicmu which means the same as:
La Deiv, no farfu e kicmu
Dave (not is-a-father) and [he is] a doctor
Dave isn't a father, but a doctor.

This is true only if he both is not a father and is a doctor, and is false otherwise. It contradicts the claim of anoi

La Deiv, farfu, enoi kicmu which is equivalent to:
La Deiv, farfu e no kicmu.
Dave (is-a-father) and (not a-doctor)
Dave is a father, but not a doctor. `

This is false if he isn't a father, or if he is a doctor. It contradicts noa.

La Deiv, farfu, noenoi kicmu which is equivalent to:
La Deiv no farfu e no kicmu
Dave (not is-a-father) and (not is-a-doctor)
Dave is neither a father nor a doctor.

If he's either one, let alone both, this is false. It contradicts a.

La Deiv, farfu, o kicmu
Dave is a father if and only if [he is] a doctor.'

This means that he must be both, or neither; it's like saying that his being a father is the same thing as being a doctor, that the two imply each other. So if the one is true, the other must also be true; and if one is false, then the other must be false as well. It contradicts both onoi and noo which are equivalent to each other.

La Deiv, farfu, onoi kicmu which is equivalent to:
La Deiv, farfu o no kicmu and
La Deiv no farfu o kicmu
Dave is a father if-and-only-if [he is] (not a-doctor)
Dave is a father or a doctor, but not both.

These sentences are true only if exactly one of the two connectands is true. However expressed, this connection is called "exclusive-or" and is probably the most frequent meaning of 'or' in English.. It contradicts o.

La Deiv, farfu, u kicmu
Dave is a father, whether he's a doctor or not.

With u, it doesn't matter whether the right connectand is true or false, so long as the left connectand is true. U contradicts the claims of nou.

La Deiv, farfu, nuu kicmu
Dave, whether a father or not, is a doctor.

This is false only if he isn't a doctor. (This order is seldom found in English.) It contradicts nuunoi.

La Deiv, farfu, nuunoi kicmu
Dave, whether a father or not, is not a doctor.

This is only false if he is a doctor; it contradicts nuu, above.

La Deiv, farfu, nou kicmu
Dave is not a father, whether he's a doctor or not.

This is true if he isn't a father, and false otherwise. This contradicts u, above.

### Lopo Purmao

CVC-form djifoa are never used at the end of predicates. They are the trickiest djifoa, because the consonant clusters they produce are sometimes ugly or simply hard to say. At such times, Logli place the hyphen y between the djifoa and whatever follows. These combinations must be hyphenated:

1. double consonants, as mekykiu eye-doctor
2. a voiceless consonant followed by its voiced counterpart (fv, kg, pb, td)
3. p, t, k, or f followed by j or z
4. any pair from the group c, j, s, z
5. bj and sb
6. the following three-letter groups:

 cdz, cvl ndj, ndz dcm, dct, dts pdz gts, gzb svl jdj, jtc, jts, jvr tvl kdz vts mzb
The y should be inserted between the first two letters of these triplets; thus sanydjano instead of *sandjano, which is a long form of saadja. (In the proscribed form, *sandjano, the d is not easy to hear.)

In case you're wondering, no, you probably won't remember all of this. These combinations are best learned through practice. If a combination doesn't sound right, hyphenate it! There are two situations where you should probably hyphenate all you can: when you're fighting noise (in a crowd, with a noisy connection on the phone, etc.), and when you're dealing with a new Logli who doesn't want to use long forms. (It's easier to recognize the djifoa in hyphenated complexes.)

There are several useful CVC djifoa, but the combining forms of the conversion operators are especially common and easy to learn. Just add -r to them: nur-, fur-, jur-. (Because it's so frequent, nu also has the djifoa nun-.) Thus, nurvia (as in Lo Nurvia Logla) comes from nu vizka (`...is seen by...against background...'). So nurvia means `seen' or `visible'. Likewise, fu vedma (`...buys...from ... at price...') becomes furvea.

### Lo Nurvia Logla

#### Le tcidaa cirhea

Hue la Karl: Loi, hoi Denys! Tu pa cirna hu vi le ckela?
Hue Dai: La Odris, djipua takna.
Hue Kai: I Oma he djipua takna?
Hue Dai: Ue ei? I no, mi saadja.
Hue Kai: Ba lodji djipua. I be ckozu djipua. I liu, a, bea, lodji djipua. I liu kou, ckozu djipua.
Hue Dai: Sii oma lodji djipua takna.
Hue Kai: Nao, tu logla cirna ha resra godzi na la Natli?
Hue Dai: E. I ui mi logla cirna, e resra godzi, noa nu kinci tu.
Hue Kai: I,sii mi titci, noa cirhea tu.
Hue Dai: I,sii mi milfa furvea, ei?
Hue Kai: I tio rea cirhea prati.
Hue Dai: Mi togri, noa tisra le resra. I ii mu godzi le mekso, a le jungo. I mi disfiu uu! I tu fundi le mekso ha le jungo?
Hue Kai: Ifeu mi fundi letupa retpi. I, e.
Hue Dai: Le mekso, e le jungo, ei?
Hue Kai: Ia. I oe tu pa cutse liu, onoi, enoi liu, a. I li, mu godzi le mekso, onoi le jungo, lu. I feu mi mutce tcidaa. I sui mu fa mordu logpli. I tu fa logla furvemcue.
Hue Dai: Io no, ba logpli vi le resra.
Hue Kai: Irea ia! I ba bi mu!

### Lo Kenti

1. Hu lodji djipua?
2. Kai fundi hu?
3. Kai titci ha cirhea Dai?
4. Ei ba logpli vi le resra?

### Lo Cninu Purda

To see the previous vocabulary.

Predicate wordsDefinitionClue words
cirhea...tutors...in subject...[CIRna HElbA = learn-help]
disfiu...is indecisive/can't decide what to do about...[DISri FIbrU = decide weak]
djipua...is a connective/conjunction of language...[DJIne PUrdA = join-word]
fundi...is more fond of...than of... (fond [FoND])
furvea...buys...from...for price...[FU (R) VEdmA = 2nd passive-sell]
furvemcue...orders...from...at price...FU (R) VEdMa CUtsE = buy-say]
jungo...is part of Chinese culture(Zhung)
kinci...accompanies...in doing...
lodji... .is a logical rule/principle for concluding/inferring ... from ... (logic [LODJIk])
mekso...is part of Mexican culture.The native pronunciation [mexiko] derived from the country name La Me'xikos will not work, as /x/ is reserved for names.
milfa...is a meal of food(s)...(meal [MIL])
prati...is a price of...to...from seller...(price [PRAIs])
resra...is a restaurant of area...(restaurant [REStaRAnt])
retpi... is an answer to question ... put by ... (reply [REPlaI])
tcastosia...is a parking lot for/of community/building...[TCAro STOlo SItfA=car-stay-place]
tcidaa...is hungry.[tiTCI DAnzA = eat-want]
tisra...chooses...from set...(choice [TcoIS])
titci...eats...(eat [IT])
vedma... sells ... to ... for price ... (vend [VEnD]market [MArket])

#### Little Words

 bea for example (freemod) [from BlEkA look at] ha "or"; how-connected-to, the interrogative connective. kou a causal connective (See chapter 10.) liu the [Loglan] word ... tio this situation, the last one mentioned.

### Summary: Lesson 6

1. "Eks" are little words which connect predicate expressions or arguments. In the case of predicate expressions, they close off whatever is to their left, so only the right-hand predicate expression's blanks are left open. You must pause (or write a comma) before an ek.

2. You must use connectives for each word connected, i.e., `x and y and z,' not `x, y, and z.'

3. Ha is an interrogative ek: it asks for a connective which will form a logically true connection. Ha questions are generally translated by `or' questions in English, and vice versa. Ei ta latci, a tidjo? `Is that light? Or [is that] heavy?' may almost always be answered Ia 'Yes', because most things under most circumstances are either light or heavy. On the other hand, Ta latci ha tidjo? `Is that light or heavy?' must be answered specifically with a connective.

### Lopo Notlensea Cirduo

 1. Ei tu ditca, onoi cirna? Are you either a teacher or learner? 2. No. Ibuo mi ditca, e cirna. I mi ditca la Inglic. Isui mi cirna la Loglan. No, but I'm [both] a teacher and a learner. I teach English; I also learn Loglan. 3. Oe mi pa cutse liu, a, onoi liu ha, ei? I should have said "and/or" or "or," huh? 4. Ia. I liu ha, gudbi liu, onoi, e liu, a, letu kenti. Yes; "or" would be better than "either/or" and "and/or" for your question. 5. Liu, onoi, e liu, a, e liu ha, lodji djipua. "Either/or", "and/or", and "or?" are logical connectives

### Lo Retpi

#### Lo Kenti

 1. What is [an example of] a logical connective? Liu, a, bea, lodji djipua. (This doesn't ask for a definition, but an example. We'll get to definitions in Lesson 15.) 2. What does K prefer? Kai fundi leDaipa retpi. 3. What does K do, eat or tutor D? Kai titci, noa cirhea Dai. (Note that noa shuts off titci's second blank, so that Carl isn't eating Dennis. Putting gu after cirhea, however - as in Kai titci, noa cirhea gu Dai - would make Dai the argument of both predicates; then K would be eating D but only if K tutors D. ) 4. Does [any]one use Loglan in the restaurant? Ia, ba logpli vi le resra. (Don't use Kai, e Dai logpli; it implies that they do so separately. We'll look at the proper connective (Kai ze Dai) in Lesson 8.)

Last Updated:Wednesday, November 29, 1995