Arthur Huntley had two engagements with D'Oyly Carte Opera Company in America. He was a chorister with Carte's First American Mikado Company in New York and Boston (August 1885-April 1886), and the following year was one of the ghosts in Ruddygore (Sir Mervyn Murgatroyd) with Carte's First American Ruddygore Company at New York's Fifth Avenue Theatre (February-April 1887). Between his American engagements he toured Germany with Carte's first Continental company.